Dear Garmin (I know you read this forum) >>>

 

What has happened to the once best GPS maker on the planet? Where did the wheels fall off for you? I ask because for years I was a Garmin devotee (330, 530, 750 and 1490) and I am feeling cheated these days.

Your latest update 5.40 created more problems (icons not working) that cost me time. No big deal say some but this is the latest in a long string of programming failures on your part. Perhaps it is time to look at your software team and think about replacing them.

What really prompts me to write this are the experiences I just had on a 1000 mile round trip from PA to Maine and back. Your routing is ABSOLUTELY horrific. No less than 6 times with my preferences set to "fastest time" I was directed off a main highway unto secondary roads. Just for instance, on the way to a hotel in Waterville Maine your routing prompted me to leave I-95 and take Maine secondary roads to a hotel I knew for a fact was less than one half mile off I-95. This happened 15-20 miles out, not around the corner. I have travelled to Maine more times than I can remember and the routing chosen by the 1490 was so far wrong that I feel sorry for anyone relying on your routing who does not have the knowledge to ignore your mistakes.

The very same thing happened elsewhere in Maine, in Connecticut on my way home and in Massachusetts returning from Maine to my Brother's home outside Boston. It also happens in my local area where I know the roads like the back of my hand and your routing tries to send me some of the most screwed up ways I could ever imagine.

Do your customers no longer matter? Do your employees have carte blanche to sabotage your business? Something is very wrong in the Stete of Garmin and your apologists are lying to you when they say all is right or this can happen with any company. I know for a fact that the misrouting and screwing up customer settings does not happen to me with some of your competitor's products.

Resting on your laurels will only get you so far. Think it over, if I am writing this there are 1000s maybe 10000s not bothering to take the time to tell you what they are thinking.

--
"You can't get there from here"
<<Page 3

Here is the direct quote>>>

philip.wood wrote:
TMK wrote:

was an intentional move on their part! The CS rep that replied claimed that they received feedback from customers that the screen was "too busy" and they took the action they did to make the icons all black dots.

IDIOTS!

Seriously? That's just plain stupid on their part. With all the traveling I do, I rely on the icons. I just shake my head at this move...

C&P from my e-mail:

For the issue with the points of interest showing the dot. We had many customers that thought the detailed information on the screen was to lets say busy so it was changed. I will gladly pass along the request and that detailed information may come back to the map detail.

With Best Regards,
Cynthia W
Product Support Specialist
2nd Shift Automotive Team
Garmin International

--
"You can't get there from here"

Survey?

TMK wrote:
philip.wood wrote:
TMK wrote:

was an intentional move on their part! The CS rep that replied claimed that they received feedback from customers that the screen was "too busy" and they took the action they did to make the icons all black dots.

IDIOTS!

Seriously? That's just plain stupid on their part. With all the traveling I do, I rely on the icons. I just shake my head at this move...

C&P from my e-mail:

For the issue with the points of interest showing the dot. We had many customers that thought the detailed information on the screen was to lets say busy so it was changed. I will gladly pass along the request and that detailed information may come back to the map detail.

With Best Regards,
Cynthia W
Product Support Specialist
2nd Shift Automotive Team
Garmin International

My question to Garmin would be what do they consider many customers 2 ,3, 10, 50,000. Also I woluld like to know how many menbers of the POI Factory have been asked to do a customer product survey for Garmin. I know I haven't.

--
Nuvi 750 and 755T

Garmin surveys

JFCTexas wrote:

Also I woluld like to know how many menbers of the POI Factory have been asked to do a customer product survey for Garmin. I know I haven't.

Interestingly, I have received 2 e-mails from Garmin asking me to participate in a customer survey. In both cases I have not been able to get past the first two questions of the survey ... 1) What is your age group 2) What is your gender. After answering those two questions, I get a message saying that my further participation in the survey is not reqired.

So I concluded that Garmin is not interested in the opinions of old males. If they ever send me another survey I am going to say I am a 29 year old female rolleyes

--
Alan - Android Auto, DriveLuxe 51LMT-S, DriveLuxe 50LMTHD, Nuvi 3597LMTHD, Oregon 550T, Nuvi 855, Nuvi 755T, Lowrance Endura Sierra, Bosch Nyon

The newer

JimD1 wrote:

But have you noticed how much nicer it is to be offered three routings on Google Maps? Why can't Garmin give us options? This is probably a major change but it sure would be more meaningfull.

The newer models do offer 3 routing options for each destination calculated. This feature, under Calculation Mode, is called "Prompted" and is available on models like the 37xx, 23xx and 24xx.

--
Nuvi 350, 760, 1695LM, 3790LMT, 2460LMT, 3597LMTHD, DriveLuxe 50LMTHD, DriveSmart 61, Garmin Drive 52, Garmin Backup Camera 40 and TomTom XXL540s.

.

alandb wrote:

So I concluded that Garmin is not interested in the opinions of old males. If they ever send me another survey I am going to say I am a 29 year old female rolleyes

Garmin should be interested in the opinions of old males. Because Garmin isn't going to find much interest in their products with the under-30 crowd. 29 year old females aren't interested in standalone gps devices, they're just gonna use their smartphone to get around.

I bet if we did a survey of this site the vast majority of members are over 40.

Plus 1 for over 40

Want to try for over 50?

GadgetGuy2008 wrote:
alandb wrote:

So I concluded that Garmin is not interested in the opinions of old males. If they ever send me another survey I am going to say I am a 29 year old female rolleyes

Garmin should be interested in the opinions of old males. Because Garmin isn't going to find much interest in their products with the under-30 crowd. 29 year old females aren't interested in standalone gps devices, they're just gonna use their smartphone to get around.

I bet if we did a survey of this site the vast majority of members are over 40.

--
Nuvi 2460LMT.

My friend use iPhone4 and give up GPS

My friend use iPhone4 and give up GPS, he is also a truck driver.

Garmin survey.

GadgetGuy2008 wrote:

Garmin should be interested in the opinions of old males. Because Garmin isn't going to find much interest in their products with the under-30 crowd. 29 year old females aren't interested in standalone gps devices, they're just gonna use their smartphone to get around.

I bet if we did a survey of this site the vast majority of members are over 40.

Perhaps that is the kind of information Garmin was trying to get at in the survey. Since they never let me proceed, I have no idea what was in the actual survey questions.

In any case, it was a poorly designed survey from a customer PR perspective as it made me feel like my opinion didn't matter.

--
Alan - Android Auto, DriveLuxe 51LMT-S, DriveLuxe 50LMTHD, Nuvi 3597LMTHD, Oregon 550T, Nuvi 855, Nuvi 755T, Lowrance Endura Sierra, Bosch Nyon

So what are good choices for dedicated GPS?

I have to admit that I haven't read all of the posts. But, like any reasonable person, I would rather get good routes. I have been using a Garmin 465WT for a while and always get to the destination. However, there have been weird routes.

Since we need a second GPS, it would be good to see what is recommended.

Thank you!

t923347 wrote:

The newer models do offer 3 routing options for each destination calculated. This feature, under Calculation Mode, is called "Prompted" and is available on models like the 37xx, 23xx and 24xx.

I've owned a 3790 for a year and literally never gave that option a second glance. Thank you for bringing it to light! grin

Dear Garmin (I know you read this forum) >>>

Felix Krull wrote:
t923347 wrote:

The newer models do offer 3 routing options for each destination calculated. This feature, under Calculation Mode, is called "Prompted" and is available on models like the 37xx, 23xx and 24xx.

I've owned a 3790 for a year and literally never gave that option a second glance. Thank you for bringing it to light! grin

I too own the 3790 and just changed the option to prompted. What can I expect when I put in a destination? I am just sitting here in the wee dark hours at the puter.

What to expect

When you select a destination, you'll wait a few seconds while it calculates the routes. Then you'll see a map with the "fastest time" route, along with distance and ETA. On the left you'll see up and down arrows which you can touch to view the "shortest distance" and "most fuel-efficient" (I forget the exact wording) routes. When you find the one you want, touch "Go", and that's the route your 3790 will use.

The good

Felix Krull wrote:

I've owned a 3790 for a year and literally never gave that option a second glance. Thank you for bringing it to light! grin

The good news is the "prompted" feature wasn't in the 3790 a year ago when we both got our units. It was added in a firmware update somewhere along the line. May have even been one of those "undocumented" additions we see on occasion. So you haven't missed it for the full year. grin

--
Nuvi 350, 760, 1695LM, 3790LMT, 2460LMT, 3597LMTHD, DriveLuxe 50LMTHD, DriveSmart 61, Garmin Drive 52, Garmin Backup Camera 40 and TomTom XXL540s.

That Helps, Thanks!

t923347 wrote:
Felix Krull wrote:

I've owned a 3790 for a year and literally never gave that option a second glance. Thank you for bringing it to light! grin

The good news is the "prompted" feature wasn't in the 3790 a year ago when we both got our units. It was added in a firmware update somewhere along the line. May have even been one of those "undocumented" additions we see on occasion. So you haven't missed it for the full year. grin

That makes me feel better. I usually go through all the menus and play with everything when I first get a new "toy", but once I get used to using it the way that makes sense for me, I tend to forget about revisiting options. When upgrades come along I install them, but unless something like a forum post about a new feature catches my eye, I don't often go looking for changes. So it's good to know it wasn't a "senior moment". Thanks.

Prompted

Felix Krull wrote:
t923347 wrote:
Felix Krull wrote:

I've owned a 3790 for a year and literally never gave that option a second glance. Thank you for bringing it to light! grin

The good news is the "prompted" feature wasn't in the 3790 a year ago when we both got our units. It was added in a firmware update somewhere along the line. May have even been one of those "undocumented" additions we see on occasion. So you haven't missed it for the full year. grin

That makes me feel better. I usually go through all the menus and play with everything when I first get a new "toy", but once I get used to using it the way that makes sense for me, I tend to forget about revisiting options. When upgrades come along I install them, but unless something like a forum post about a new feature catches my eye, I don't often go looking for changes. So it's good to know it wasn't a "senior moment". Thanks.

I notice when using prompted, and using the shortest route, if the gps has to recalculate it goes to the fastest time route not the shortest as orginaly chosen

--
Today is a gift, that's why they call it the present...

It doesn't matter

alandb wrote:
GadgetGuy2008 wrote:

Garmin should be interested in the opinions of old males. Because Garmin isn't going to find much interest in their products with the under-30 crowd. 29 year old females aren't interested in standalone gps devices, they're just gonna use their smartphone to get around.

I bet if we did a survey of this site the vast majority of members are over 40.

Perhaps that is the kind of information Garmin was trying to get at in the survey. Since they never let me proceed, I have no idea what was in the actual survey questions.

In any case, it was a poorly designed survey from a customer PR perspective as it made me feel like my opinion didn't matter.

Alandb

With the surveys design, what make you think anyone's perspective matters. Its probably to late for Garmin to ever regain the cornered market again anyway.

They blew it by not staying on the cutting edge, when they failed to develop a common android app. Instead they decided to stay greedy and keep their app closed architecture and not using the open google OS by getting in bed with Asus and created the Nuvi Phone. Buy doing so they have lost a large segment of the smartphone market under the Garmin name for the next few years.

--
Using Android Based GPS.The above post and my sig reflects my own opinions, expressed for the purpose of informing or inspiring, not commanding. Naturally, you are free to reject or embrace whatever you read.

Driving in South Texas - where am I????

We were driving on some "newer" roads in South Texas around Lake Jackson, and suddenly we were out in the middle of nowhere according to the Garmin. I updated maps earlier this summer, and those roads aren't that new! Wow, that was strange! Good news is we did get back onto the roads, but if we'd followed the GPS, we'd have wound up in the water! Blub!

I love my Garmin and have

I love my Garmin and have had no problems that common sense fixed.

Rath *Proud owner*

--
Garmin 1390T X1 & 50LM

I've had a 3590 about 6

I've had a 3590 about 6 years now. Occasional strange routing as previously noted, but overall it works good. A few years back I bought a new Jeep but never activated the built in GPS until they offered a discount. The built in one is horrible. I don't think it ever updates, and trying to put in someplace to go is a challenge at best. My 3590 still travels with me, so when I get tired of battling with the built in GPS the 3590 comes to the rescue. Once at my destination I set the built in one to save the location for next time.

I can't speak about the newer Garmins since I don't have one. However there is one way, although a slow one to get Garmin's attention. Stop buying them. They will either do a better job or loose that portion of their business. As for the 3590, I like it. Hopefully my opinion won't change after having downloading all the latest updates.

GPS vs Phone

I have had a Garmin GPS for a long time (different Models)
l I have a Hyundai Tucson and with the Android Auto app is easier to use and is always updated (no typing in address, just tell it where I want to go even ask for a business)
It tells me if there is traffic and will route me around it.
I understand most of the cars today will do the same thing.
It uses Google maps and very little data.
I am a senior citizen and my children and grandchildren all use their smart phones, doessn't Garmin understand that it is usually the older people who buy a GPS
todays youth are too Hi-Tech to use a stand alone GPS.

--
Don't sweat the petty things and don't pet the sweaty things!

Choice # 1 - Garmin

My use of Garmin's spans more than 20 years.

No extra charges, no "accidental" connection fees.

With lifetime traffic and free map updates, I couldn't ask for more.

My travels have spanned 50 states and 6 Canadian provinces without the use of a map. None!

Look around and there's Garmins on planes , ships, boats, trucks, buses, cycles, automobiles and riding around in hiker's hip pockets.

Bravo Garmin. Job well done!

An Old Thread But Still An Issue

I too have been using Garmin's for a couple of decades. It appears the problems reported by the OP almost 10 years ago are still with us today.

These "hickups" and glitches in firmware and map updates are the reason I now do them infrequently. I never do an update when first released and wait until the wrinkles have been ironed out. Even then, I'll sometimes go 2 or 3 years between updates.

I still use and love my Garmins though.

Try Reset or Reboot?

This hasn't happened to me recently, but I remember a time when my nuvi would -- for some strange reason -- route me through side streets rather than keep me on the main roads. I have no idea why it glitched like that, but a reboot sometimes helps.

Navigation got changed from

Navigation got changed from Fastest Route to Shortest Route.

--
Frank DriveSmart55 37.322760, -79.511267

Nuvi 1490

I found a Nuvi 1490 in a thrift shop and brought it home, did a factory reset, then a complete map update. When I tried to use it to navigate to a town about an hour away it was showing an arrival time 3 1/2 hours later. After viewing the route map it would have taken me that long to drive that route. I think I'll stick with my Nuvi 265.

Check Settings>Navigation

Check Settings>Navigation and see what the route settings are. Should be Fastest.

Also check Settings>Maps and make sure all the current maps are installed and checked to use.

--
Frank DriveSmart55 37.322760, -79.511267

I don't think so...

RayHff wrote:

My use of Garmin's spans more than 20 years.

No extra charges, no "accidental" connection fees.

With lifetime traffic and free map updates, I couldn't ask for more.

My travels have spanned 50 states and 6 Canadian provinces without the use of a map. None!

Look around and there's Garmins on planes , ships, boats, trucks, buses, cycles, automobiles and riding around in hiker's hip pockets.

I am sorry. I just don't see what you're seeing. I wish I did.

Furthermore, I assume the aviation and marine world still use Garmin, but with rare exception buses, hikers, bikers including cyclists everyone is using their iPhone or Android including their in-vehicle peripherals for navigation. Remember, "there's an app for that".

But..

Probably would come as a surprise to some.. but there are still a lot of us that do not have a smartphone and see no reason to have one. My "flip phone" does all I need while driving.

--
Lives in Edmonton AB A volunteer driver for Drive Happiness.ca and now (since June 20 2021) uses a DS65 to find his clients.

Go out west. Cell service

Go out west. Cell service is spotty, at best. Only time I've lost satellite service was inn HEAVY tree cover. 50 minutes from any cell service.

--
Frank DriveSmart55 37.322760, -79.511267

Smart Phones Are Okay Too

To Sam888, please let me be clear, I never said the phones were bad. Pricey maybe; bad no. Stores still stock all those Garmins, Magellans, Tom Toms, etc. because folks are buying them.

#1 - My Garmins have served me well.

#2 - I am cheap; and, as a result if I need to look something up on the road, I use a "WIFI only" tablet.

For communication, I use a T-Mobile flip phone that costs $ 21.00 a month -- that includes tax, tag, title, everything. That's on top of my Garmin which is free.

I figured, if a flipper's good enough for Warren Buffett and folks like Ralph6410, that's probably all I need.

Some love their smart phone, and that's great. We all enjoy different things and spend our money in different ways.

We're all different.

Not me

Sam888 wrote:

I am sorry. I just don't see what you're seeing. I wish I did.

Furthermore, I assume the aviation and marine world still use Garmin, but with rare exception buses, hikers, bikers including cyclists everyone is using their iPhone or Android including their in-vehicle peripherals for navigation. Remember, "there's an app for that".

Sorry but I disagree. I don't use my phone for navigation when walking, my Garmin GPS is far easier to use and hold in my hand. My phone stays in my pack although it does have maps and a nav app on it should my GPS fail, although it never has yet.

As for driving, I use my Garmin. My wife's car has Android auto that we use with Google maps, fine for a quick point to point route but rubbish if you want to have more control over where you're going.

So 'everyone' is not using their phones smile

--
Where there's a will ... there's a way ... DriveSmart51LMT-S, DriveSmart50LMT-D, Nuvi 2508LMT-D, 1490LMT, 1310, Montana 650T, Etrex 20

Agreed

sussamb wrote:
Sam888 wrote:

I am sorry. I just don't see what you're seeing. I wish I did.

Furthermore, I assume the aviation and marine world still use Garmin, but with rare exception buses, hikers, bikers including cyclists everyone is using their iPhone or Android including their in-vehicle peripherals for navigation. Remember, "there's an app for that".

Sorry but I disagree. I don't use my phone for navigation when walking, my Garmin GPS is far easier to use and hold in my hand. My phone stays in my pack although it does have maps and a nav app on it should my GPS fail, although it never has yet.

As for driving, I use my Garmin. My wife's car has Android auto that we use with Google maps, fine for a quick point to point route but rubbish if you want to have more control over where you're going.

So 'everyone' is not using their phones smile

Using a smartphone as a handheld GPS isn't practical for continuous use. The battery drain is too high. An external power source from a vehicle or portable power bank is necessary.

If you're going to carry a power bank in your pocket, why not just use a handheld GPS and save the smartphone battery for an emergency.

Also, if you're like me, you use a boatload of waypoints with your handheld which are difficult to upload to a smartphone.

There are also laws against holding your dellphone

In Virginia there is now a law that says "Hands Free" only for cell phones. Luckily my pickup has Bluetooth that I can use to talk on the phone, if needed.

What I don't understand is why Garmin doesn't point out in their advertising the advantages of a stand alone GPS. A stand alone has superior routing, more onboard POIs, easily added Custom POIs and a host of other advantages. AND, if you get a LMT version, you won't be spending over $100(USD) for map updates (depending on vehicle manufacturer) as well as fast re-routing around traffic jams.

They are missing out by not promoting the advantages.

--
Metricman DriveSmart 76 Williamsburg, VA

Because maybe there's more

Because maybe there's more money in the wearable and sports watches end of the business. The standalone GPS as we use it is not how the majority of others use it.

My friends, and even my brother, bought a Nuvi GPS and NEVER updated the map or loaded any POIs. Too much "bother", even after I showed them how to do it.

That market of people is WAY bigger that the market of us GPS fanatics. They are perfectly happy using whatever the car manufacter has in the vehicle, heck, most of them probably never ever ask the sales people about the built-in GPS.

My stepdaugher uses google maps on her phone in a vent-holder, doesn't touch the phone any more than I touch my GPS when driving. Why would she want a standalone GPS? I can't think of a single reason to even offer her a standalnoe GPS. She wouldn't use it. Too much bother.

--
I never get lost, but I do explore new territory every now and then.

I thought that you were going to make the case...

metricman wrote:

In Virginia there is now a law that says "Hands Free" only for cell phones. Luckily my pickup has Bluetooth that I can use to talk on the phone, if needed.

What I don't understand is why Garmin doesn't point out in their advertising the advantages of a stand alone GPS. A stand alone has superior routing, more onboard POIs, easily added Custom POIs and a host of other advantages. AND, if you get a LMT version, you won't be spending over $100(USD) for map updates (depending on vehicle manufacturer) as well as fast re-routing around traffic jams.

They are missing out by not promoting the advantages.

I thought that you were going to make the case that the GPS (at least in the case of my DriveSmart 51LMT-S) the the GPS provides satisfactory bluetooth and audio for hands-free phone usage too.

Garmin Nuvi

I love my Garmin NUVI for its ease of use but I have to admit the navigation can be crazy at times. I find that it often goes in circles to get the same place a straight path would have taken you. Also, I find that many places are not listed when you do a search, places that have been there for years. I hope they do listen and do better.

Growth vs Sustainable

Way back when Garmin was growing fast because of massive demand, they had money to spare. They were selling anything they came up with, a GPS was a marvel, everybody wanted one, and they paid big bucks. Nowadays, with GPS in smartphones, there is tense competition and capital is much tighter, meaning Garmin had to cut back in capacity and capability. Sounds like customer service took a major hit.

--
When you are dead, you don’t know that you are dead. It is only difficult for the others. It is the same when you are stupid.

Doing Just Fine

Garmin's doing just fine. Their stock is trading at $ 157, roughly 58% up over a year ago. Sweet!!

Street names VS Highway numbers. Also agree with TMK's comments

Garmin Nuvi 765T Maps: 2022.20

We just came back from a very disappointing Garmin trip experience. Not only did we have to override Garmin's navigation several times, but we have one other MAJOR irritant.

We were on or seeking state highways in and around towns but you would never find them with Garmin. Garmin ONLY provided local nondescript street names that were totally useless.

Luckily, My wife’s iPad has the Google Map App which gave us a blue dot locator and more info. Also, I have a non-supported Rand McNally RVND unit that gave us highway numbers and street names.

We should not have the driving distraction of consulting multiple GPS sources to figure what damn highway are on or watching for. City street names ONLY? REALLY???? What a crock.

Garmin failed us at time I am shopping with the idea of buying a new Garmin RV1090, but I am rethinking that now.

--
rvOutrider

Hmmm

Not sure why you were "seeking state highways". Your GPS is a routing device with the aim of getting you from A to B. My experience is it does that very well. You can input destinations from within its database, including addresses, cities, POIs etc. You can even input road intersections. Having done so it gives you directions to get there.

It isn't linked to the Internet so if you want to Google for stuff you need to use another device. It has always been thus.

Incidentally your GPS is a fairly old device. Modern devices even give instructions such as turn left at the traffic lights.

--
Where there's a will ... there's a way ... DriveSmart51LMT-S, DriveSmart50LMT-D, Nuvi 2508LMT-D, 1490LMT, 1310, Montana 650T, Etrex 20

customer service

Brad Bishop wrote:

I remember the 1490 having some bad problems when it was first released. They had a lot of returns. They fixed the units (I think it was just new firmware) and sent them back out.

I bought a refurbished 1490 a few years back and it was always stable for me. I don't ever remember it resetting or doing anything stupid. The only thing that bugged me was some missing features (from StreetPilot days). Functionally, the refurbished unit I had was fine, though.

I think the 1490 was one of their worst screw ups.

I had a 1490. I liked it except that it developed the random reboot problem. Then a SW update bricked it and Garmin replaced it with a new Drive 55.

The same SW update bricked my 765 and they replaced that also.

That is pretty good customer service.

Yes, they do have problems occasionally, but it sure is WAY better than my 2014 Toyota Rav4 nav system.

I think

sussamb wrote:

Not sure why you were "seeking state highways". Your GPS is a routing device with the aim of getting you from A to B. My experience is it does that very well. You can input destinations from within its database, including addresses, cities, POIs etc. You can even input road intersections. Having done so it gives you directions to get there.

It isn't linked to the Internet so if you want to Google for stuff you need to use another device. It has always been thus.

Incidentally your GPS is a fairly old device. Modern devices even give instructions such as turn left at the traffic lights.

I think the complaint is that the Garmin often only show Highway Names when Highway Numbers maybe of more value.

--
Nuvi 350, 760, 1695LM, 3790LMT, 2460LMT, 3597LMTHD, DriveLuxe 50LMTHD, DriveSmart 61, Garmin Drive 52, Garmin Backup Camera 40 and TomTom XXL540s.
<<Page 3